✕

Parliament think tank faults Ruto for unfulfilled promises and rising debts

Financial Standard
By Brian Ngugi and Macharia Kamau | Nov 17, 2026

President William Ruto, Speakers Moses Wetangula and Amason Kingi during the opening of the Third Global Parliamentary Summit against Hunger and Malnutrition at Parliament Buildings, Nairobi, on November 16, 2026. [Elvis Ogina, Standard]  

President William Ruto’s administration is entering a critical election year with a message of economic redemption, but a new report from Parliament’s fiscal watchdog has punctured that narrative.

The budget experts have faulted the government for stalled growth, reckless borrowing, a broken labour market and unfulfilled development promises.

With the General Election scheduled for August 10, 2027, Ruto has already begun telling supporters that his administration has delivered on its bottom-up economic agenda, pointing to falling inflation and a resilient economy.

However, the Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO), in a new report published this month and reviewed by Financial Standard, paints a different picture.

It shows an economy that is merely treading water, a government unable to collect the taxes it budgets for and a labour market that is shrinking rather than expanding.

The PBO's central critique is that Kenya's economy has not accelerated, despite the Ruto government's repeated claims of economic recovery.

The report notes that real gross domestic product (GDP) growth averaged about 4.6 per cent annually between 2017 and 2025.

While the economy expanded by 5.1 per cent in the first two quarters of this year, the experts caution that this "signals stability, but does not represent a completed annual result."

More damning is the comparison with the government's own targets. "Growth remained below the 6.5 per cent envisaged under MTP IV (the fourth medium term plan of Vision 2030) by 2025, increasing the cost of living and potentially constraining household purchasing power and private investment,” said PBO in its Budget Watch report titled, Strengthening Efficiency in Public Expenditure.

The report also identifies a troubling trend where growth is being driven not by innovation or efficiency, but by simply adding more workers and capital.

Total Factor Productivity (TFP), which measures the efficiency with which labour and capital are combined to produce output, fell 15.5 per cent between 2015 and 2025.

"The sustained decline suggests that gains from efficiency, technology and the productivity of existing resources have not kept pace with the expansion of labour and capital inputs," the report states.

In simpler terms, Kenya's economy is running harder but not smarter. The report points out that TFP growth weakened to a mere 0.6 per cent in 2024 and 0.5 per cent in 2025, a fraction of the 3.1 per cent and 3.0 per cent seen in 2018 and 2019.

The PBO's fiscal critique is also damning. Revenue collection in the 2025/26 financial year missed its target by Sh60.2 billion, while interest payments on public debt ballooned to Sh1.074 trillion.

Public debt reached Sh13.1 trillion at the end of June 2026. The government is also spending more servicing its obligations than it is collecting from its citizens.

The report also flags a worrying trend of "crowding out" the private sector. “Periods of stronger government credit growth sometimes coincided with weaker private sector credit (PSC) growth," the PBO notes.

When the government borrows heavily, it absorbs the available capital, leaving businesses and households with fewer and more expensive options for financing.

"This suggests that credit growth also depends on factors that may include demand, lending conditions and competition for available financial resources," said the parliamentary budget experts.

The report also criticises the government's reliance on debt to fund its promises.

The financial year 2027/28 budget is projected at Sh5.303 trillion under the baseline, with a fiscal deficit of 6.2 per cent of GDP.

While this is only marginally higher than the six per cent deficit under the alternative scenario, it underscores the government's continued dependence on borrowing to bridge the gap between what it collects and what it spends.

Perhaps the most politically charged findings concern Kenya's labour market. The PBO's data reveals a disturbing decline in the employment-to-population ratio, which fell from 69.7 per cent in 2017 to 63.7 per cent in 2025.

Labour force participation also dropped, from 72.3 per cent to 67.4 per cent over the same period. The unemployment rate rose from 3.5 per cent to 5.4 per cent.

"Although Kenya's unemployment rate (at 5.4 per cent) remained below the  Sub-Saharan African average of 5.7 per cent in 2025, lower participation suggests that labour market challenges extend beyond unemployment," the report warns.

"They also concern the economy's ability to engage the working-age population in employment or active job search."

In plain terms, Kenyans are giving up on looking for work. The government has promised to create jobs, particularly for young people, but the data suggests the opposite: fewer people are participating in the labour market, and fewer still are finding employment.

The report offers an example of the structural problem: "Agriculture represented about 23 per cent of GDP in 2025, leaving output exposed to rainfall variability. Manufacturing accounted for under eight per cent of real output that year and grew by 2.2 per cent in Q2 2026."

The experts have a remedy: "Declining TFP underscores the need for MTP IV and BETA interventions to raise productivity as well as investment and employment. Priorities include technology adoption, skills development, infrastructure, industrialisation and support for productive sectors and Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs)."

On inflation, the PBO offers a nuanced critique.

Headline inflation rose from 4.6 per cent in September 2025 to 6.8 per cent in September 2026, remaining within the Central Bank of Kenya's target range.

But the report highlights the painful composition of that inflation, noting that "non-core inflation increased sharply from 9.6 per cent in September 2025 to 14.0 per cent in September 2026," driven by higher energy and food prices.

"The resulting 5.8 percentage-point gap in 2025 highlights food and energy prices as the main risks to price stability and household living costs," the PBO states.

For ordinary Kenyans, this translates into an unrelenting squeeze on household budgets: unga, fuel and electricity have all become more expensive, even as wages remain stagnant.

The experts warn that "sustained price stability will depend on containing supply-side pressures while maintaining prudent monetary policy."

The PBO's recommendations reflect a philosophy of fiscal prudence.  The report proposes budget options worth Sh9.85 billion in the financial year 2027/28, alongside an existing Sh20 billion commitment to raise domestic health spending.

But the underlying message is clear that the government cannot spend its way out of its problems.

"Most options can be implemented with current resources," the report states.

The largest new proposal is Sh7.85 billion to expand bilateral labour agreements, standardise pre-departure training and strengthen the National Employment Authority.

This is an admission that the domestic labour market is failing to absorb Kenyan workers, and that the government is increasingly relying on exporting labour to Gulf states and other destinations.

The experts recommend "expanding Bilateral Labour Agreements; standardise pre-departure training; strengthen the National Employment Authority and its digital systems; fund migrant welfare and protection; support return and reintegration."

A further Sh2 billion is proposed to raise research funding progressively towards two per cent of GDP.

The report calls for the government to "raise research funding progressively towards two per cent of GDP; establish a functioning research and innovation infrastructure; encourage private investment in research."

On housing, the PBO urges the government to "prioritise mortgage financing for affordable units; direct Tenant Purchase Schemes and deposit assistance to social housing, encourage cash purchases and improve the Boma Yangu allocation process."

For the long-stalled Lokichar-Lamu crude oil pipeline, the experts advise the government to "update the feasibility and bankability assessment, revive regional commercial negotiations, develop the pipeline in phases with private partners."

The timing of the PBO report is significant. With elections set for August 10 next year, the budget cycle is being accelerated to accommodate the political calendar.

The Budget Policy Statement is to be approved by mid-December 2026, with the Appropriations Bill and Finance Bill passed by the end of March 2027.

This means the government's fiscal plans will be scrutinised by Parliament and the public at the height of the election campaign.

Ruto's allies have pointed to the 5.1 per cent growth in the first half of 2026, the stability of the shilling and the gradual easing of inflation as evidence of progress.

But the PBO's report cites missed revenue targets, soaring debt, declining productivity, falling employment and a labour market that is shrinking rather than expanding.

"The economy remains resilient, but growth has not accelerated,” said the report.

Share this story
East African businesses turn to outsourced logistics as regional trade grows
The growth of online commerce is increasing demand for transportation services covering the entire supply chain.
Kassait wins global privacy award as Kenya and EU advance data adequacy deal
The milestone brings Kenya closer to becoming the first African country to secure a mutual data adequacy arrangement with the EU.
From Bomas to major roads and airports: How contract blunders are hurting taxpayers
The government stripped the Turkish contractor Summa of the Bomas project and handed the repriced contract to CRBC, which has seen the cost of the project rise to Sh45.1 billion.
Parliament think tank faults Ruto for unfulfilled promises and rising debts
President William Ruto’s administration is entering a critical election year with a message of economic redemption, but a new report from Parliament’s fiscal watchdog has punctured that narrative.
Kenya backs AU's new financing model pushing to raise Sh155b
Kenya has called on AU member states to implement a 0.2 per cent levy on eligible imports, backing a financing mechanism projected to raise approximately Sh155 billion annually.
.
RECOMMENDED NEWS