✕

Kenya's vulnerable children are paying the price of unequal devolution

Opinion
By Dennis Kabaara | Nov 17, 2026

President William Ruto during the opening of the Third Global Parliamentary Summit Against Hunger and Malnutrition in Parliament, Nairobi, on November 16, 2026. [PCS, Standard]

The 2027 electoral season is simmering quite nicely. On one side, a broad-based government speaking the equalising language of “Usawa Ni Sawa”; on the other a united opposition essentially organising itself around ethnic blocs in its search for the highest office. Both sides are quick to preach the usual song of national unity to Kenyans who are themselves already united in the search for a better Kenya. This is where the “development” mantra shines though we haven’t quite agreed on what this means. Is it a state lodge, sports stadium or new road in every county as a completed activity, equal standards of service delivery in, say, health, as an output, or is it outcomes in terms of human welfare and wellbeing?

Fortunately, we have agencies such as the excellent Kenya National Bureau of Statistics (KNBS) that help us to elevate this question beyond political rhetoric, roadside declarations and government press statements to credible data and information. Which brings us to their latest publication effort – the 2025/26 Kenya Mini-Demographic and Health Survey (KMDHS) developed in conjunction with the Ministry of Health and publicly launched a fortnight ago with little fanfare, but some news to celebrate.

This KMDHS, which follows the full 2022 edition, shows we are moving forward. Nationally, 91 per cent of births now take place in health facilities, up from 88 per cent in 2022. 72 per cent of pregnant women complete at least four antenatal visits, total fertility has eased to 3.1 children per woman, and under-five mortality has declined to 37 deaths per 1,000 live births.  But national averages are illusory, they don’t offer a true “Usawa Ni Sawa”picture. Warm as an average is your feet in the oven and head in the fridge.

So, let’s examine some data snippets from four counties representing different political regions and socio-economic extremes – Kiambu in Central, Makueni in Eastern, Kakamega in Western, and Turkana in the North Rift. Here is where the KMDHS tells us the story behind the applause. It is the story of an intergenerational fault line where a Kenyan child’s cognitive, physical and economic trajectory is locked in before age five, and a misunderstood version of devolution is failing to use this baseline to break the cycle.

The Intergenerational Chain: Life Chances Before Kindergarten

Demographic surveys do not track the same individuals across decades, yet by measuring maternal schooling, household infrastructure and toddler development inside the same homes, the 2025–26 KMDHS maps how advantage and vulnerability pass from mother to child across three stages.

First is the mother’s starting line. In Kiambu, only 1 per cent of women aged 15 to 49 lack formal schooling, and teenage pregnancy stands at 6 per cent. In Makueni, the share of women without formal education is virtually zero, and teen pregnancy sits at 4 per cent. Contrast that with Kakamega, where teen pregnancy reaches 16 per cent, and Turkana, where 52 per cent of women have never attended school and 19 per cent of girls aged 15 to 19 have already been pregnant. When a girl leaves school or enters motherhood early, her household starts with lower earning power and greater health risk, passing economic fragility to the next generation.

Second is the daily household environment tax. While 75 per cent of households in Kiambu rely on clean fuels for cooking, heating and lighting, this collapses to 10 per cent in Makueni, 7 per cent in Kakamega, and just 2 per cent in Turkana, where only 15 per cent of homes also have basic sanitation. It isn’t rocket science that growing up in smoke-filled kitchens without clean water or sanitation exposes infants to chronic illnesses, before we get to girls performing firewood and water fetching chores at study time.

Third is the early childhood payoff, which has been captured for the first time in Kenya using the World Health Organization’s Global Scales for Early Development (GSED) for children aged 3 to 59 months. Across Kiambu (89 per cent), Makueni (89 per cent), and Kakamega (88 per cent), nearly nine in ten toddlers are developmentally on track cognitively, socially, and physically.  In Turkana, that figure collapses to 56 per cent. In summary, before a child in Turkana steps into an ECDE classroom, earlier compounding maternal and household deficits have already narrowed their starting gate.

Complicating the Narrative: What Changed Since 2022?

This is not a simple narrative about rich urban winners and poor rural losers.  When we compare these county trajectories between 2022 and 2025/26, we can see more clearly where progress happens.

Makueni and Kiambu, by example, demonstrate how rapid gains can occur when health and social systems align. Teenage pregnancy was cut in half in Kiambu, falling from 12 per cent to 6 per cent, while Makueni drove teen pregnancy down from 11 per cent to 4 per cent, boosted basic sanitation by 25 percentage points to 71 per cent, and pushed four-plus ante-natal care attendance up 13 points to 89 per cent.

Kakamega, by contrast, illustrates the trap of clinic access without household transformation. Although 93 per cent of Kakamega’s births take place in health facilities and toddler development remains high at 88 per cent, teenage pregnancy edged upward from 15 per cent in 2022 to 16 per cent, while clean fuel adoption is stuck at 7 per cent.  Hospitals alone cannot lift families out of energy and adolescent poverty.

Turkana is an incomplete bridge. Women attending four-plus antenatal visits jumped from roughly 35 per cent in 2022 to 51 per cent, proving outreach is reaching expectant mothers.  Yet facility deliveries stayed stuck at 52 per cent – virtually unchanged from 53 per cent skilled births in 2022 – while teen pregnancy remained frozen at 19 per cent and clean fuels at 2 per cent.  Mothers get checked during pregnancy, but vast distances, transport gaps and sparse facilities force nearly half to give birth at home. 

Nationally, urban hubs like Nairobi also saw teen pregnancy climb from 8.4 per cent to 13.2 per cent, reminding planners that urban proximity no longer guarantees adolescent protection.

Misunderstood Devolution: Why We Budget on Guesswork

This four-county divergence exposes a deeper governance problem: we continue to misinterpret devolution as a cash-transfer pipeline rather than a problem-solving laboratory.  In federal systems like the US, states raise local revenues, run local public health and statistical tracking, and operate as policy laboratories – testing local interventions for local problems while answering directly to local taxpayers.

Under our 2010 Constitution, devolution sought to cure historical marginalisation, yet our fiscal and political habits are centralised. With so much reliance on the Equitable Share, debate focuses on how much money is shared and not the bottlenecks each shilling fixes.  Arguably, counties treat KNBS fact sheets as external report cards, not operational baselines. Three planning contradictions stand out.

First, county budgets favour visible concrete (brick and mortar) over effective services such as healthcare. Second, national reforms (like SHA) rely on uniform rollouts despite diverging local realities. Third, lagging counties rarely copy what works next door; we haven’t institutionalized peer-review as a force for good.

Raising the Bar: From Ceremonial Report to Citizen Contract

The real point from this KMDHS is that it calls us to raise our statistical bar if we are to address inequality. By example, global statistical leaders pair periodic household surveys such as this one with continuous administrative records linked safely through trusted digital identity, localized geo-mapping and routine citizen-satisfaction modules that measure quality and affordability alongside physical access.  The big ask and opportunity for KNBS here is to turn our currently static snapshots into living management tools.

Ultimately, however, better data only matters if citizens and politicians refuse to let publications such as this KMDHS gather dust.  We should be asking counties to map their worst KMDHS indicators against proposed resource allocations during public participation events and budget hearings.  Because if we keep budgeting on political guesswork while hiding behind flattering national averages, we are not merely misreading our excellent statistical data, we are rationing the future of our children by county code.

Share this story
'Kenya have nothing to lose' - Mosimane warns Bafana Bafana against underestimating Harambee Stars
South Africa head coach Pitso Mosimane has warned Bafana Bafana against underestimating Harambee Stars, cautioning that Kenya could be a difficult opponent
Why Bafana Bafana head coach Pitso Mosimane has a special place in his heart for Kenya
South Africa head coach Pitso Mosimane opened up a deeply personal connection to Kenya, disclosing that members of his family sought refuge in the country during the apartheid era
McCarthy lays down the gauntlet as Bafana Bafana come calling
Tonight, McCarthy's Harambee Stars play for something bigger than points when they welcome South Africa's Bafana Bafana, and the terraces have a job to do too.
Shah shines at Sigona Chairman's prize meet
16-year-old junior sensation, Hetansh Shah, delivered a clinical two-day performance to capture the 2026 Sigona Golf Club Chairman's prize.
Samoei set for Nyuki marathon title defence
Defending champion Norah Samoei from Iten is among elite athletes who are looking forward to take part in the third edition of Nyuki Marathon set for Uhuru Park in Nairobi on February 7, 2027.
.
RECOMMENDED NEWS