✕

Revealed: Judges, Magistrate individual performance scorecard exposed

National
By Nancy Gitonga | Nov 21, 2026
President William Ruto during his  State of the Nation Address at Parliament, Nairobi. November 18,2026. [Elvis Ogina, Standard]

For the first time in Kenya’s history, judges and magistrates have been placed under the public spotlight, with the Judiciary publishing individual performance records showing how many judgments, rulings and cases they have handled.

In a landmark transparency move, the Judiciary has disclosed the individual output of judges, magistrates, Kadhis and Small Claims Court adjudicators in its 2025/2026 State of the Judiciary and Administration of Justice Report.

The disclosure marks a major shift in how the institution accounts for the exercise of judicial authority. It opens the work of individual judicial officers to public scrutiny beyond the traditional reporting of performance at court and station level.

The report, released yesterday morning and shared on Judiciary social media platforms, covers the financial year between July 1, 2025 and June 30, 2026. It contains detailed schedules showing the names of judicial officers and their recorded output in four categories: judgments delivered, rulings closing cases, interlocutory rulings and other resolutions.

The figures were extracted from the Judiciary’s Case Tracking System (CTS) and cover the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, High Court, Environment and Land Court, Employment and Labour Relations Court, Magistrates’ Courts, Kadhis’ Courts and Small Claims Court.

But behind the unprecedented disclosure lies a controversial question: which judicial officers delivered the most decisions, and who recorded the lowest output during the year?

The publication comes four months after Chief Justice Martha Koome announced that individual performance records would be made public, arguing that the Judiciary must account to Kenyans, who finance and depend on the institution.

On July 3, 2026, Koome announced the initiative while unveiling the 2024/2025 Performance Management and Measurement Understanding evaluation report.

“As part of ongoing efforts to strengthen accountability, enhance transparency and deepen public confidence in the administration of justice, the Judiciary will begin publishing individual performance reports for judges and judicial officers from July 2026,” she announced.

The announcement, however, triggered opposition, with Nairobi resident Duncan Kariuki moving to court to stop the publication.

Through lawyer Harun Njoroge, Kariuki argued that releasing the figures without a clear legal and policy framework would expose judges to ridicule, cyber harassment and threats to their independence.

“The intended publication exposes Judges and Judicial Officers to the real risk of ridicule, doxxing, cyber harassment and other threats to their personal security and independence, thereby posing a direct threat to the administration of justice,” Njoroge argued.

The lawyer further warned that publishing raw statistics could turn judges into “judgment and ruling-churning machines”, prioritising the number of decisions delivered over their quality.

The Kenya Magistrates and Judges Association (KMJA) also supported transparency but questioned the timing of the publication, citing an incomplete Case Weighting Study and gaps in the digitisation of the CTS.

“The Association supports transparency in judicial performance reporting as a matter of principle. We have, however, separately written to the Honourable Chief Justice to request that publication of individual performance reports be sequenced appropriately, given the still-incomplete Case Weighting Study and outstanding gaps in CTS digitisation, so that the data published is fair, accurate and genuinely comparable across stations,” KMJA President Justice Peter Mulwa said.

He maintained that the request was about proper sequencing rather than opposition to accountability.

 Vihiga High Court Judge Reuben Nyakundi. 

An examination of the High Court’s individual performance schedules shows that Vihiga High Court Judge Reuben Nyakundi recorded the highest output, with 1,791 determinations. He delivered 170 judgments, 825 rulings closing cases, 555 interlocutory rulings and 241 other resolutions.

He was followed by Kisumu High Court Judge Alfred Mabeya with 968 recorded outputs, comprising 160 judgments, 279 final rulings, 63 interlocutory rulings and 466 other resolutions.

Justice Teresa Odera of the Nakuru High Court recorded 956 outputs, while Justice Richard Mwongo of the Kerugoya High Court had 913. Justice Teresia Matheka of the Makueni High Court recorded 906 outputs.

Justice Dennis Kizito Magare of the Mombasa High Court was also among the leading judicial officers, recording 904 outputs, including 375 judgments, during the 2025/2026 reporting period.

The report also reveals significant differences in the recorded output of judges serving at the High Court, with some handling hundreds of matters while others registered only a handful during the year under review.

Justice Winnie Narasha Molonko, listed under the Milimani Commercial and Tax Division, recorded two outputs, comprising no judgments, no final rulings, no interlocutory rulings and two other resolutions.

Justice Joseph Were, listed at the Kitale High Court, recorded eight outputs, comprising two judgments, one ruling closing a case, no interlocutory rulings and five other resolutions.

Justice Winnie Narasha Molonko recorded two outputs, comprising no judgments, no final rulings, no interlocutory rulings and two other resolutions.

Other judges with relatively low individual recorded outputs included Justice Joseph Kipkoech Biomdo, who recorded 19 outputs at the Milimani Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Division; Justice David Wanjohi Mburu, who had 20 outputs at the Milimani Constitution and Human Rights Division, comprising 18 judgments, one ruling closing a case and one interlocutory ruling; and Justice Francis Nyungu Kyambia, who recorded 21 outputs, including 19 judgments and two other resolutions.

The Judiciary, however, cautions against treating the figures as a definitive ranking of judicial performance. It notes that the period served, case complexity, station conditions, deployment, partial-year service, work undertaken at other court stations, workload and administrative responsibilities all affect individual output.

Milimani divisions

At Milimani, the figures provide a particularly interesting picture of judicial output across the different divisions.

In the Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Division, Justice Rose Ougo recorded 497 outputs, followed by Justice Benjamin Musyoki with 256 and newly appointed Justice Joseph Kipkoech Biomdo with 19. The division recorded 852 outputs collectively.

The Civil Appellate Division recorded 2,729 outputs. Justice Mwanaisha Saida led with 778, followed by Justice Janet Mulwa with 570, Justice Linus Kassan with 463, Justice Wilfrida Okwany with 473, Justice Antony Mrima with 305 and Principal Judge Eric Kennedy Ogola with 140.

In the Civil Division, Justice Stella Mutuku recorded 433 outputs, Justice Kennedy Lenkamai Kandet 42 and Justice Anne Mary Okutoyi 30, bringing the division’s total to 505.

The Commercial and Tax Division recorded 3,964 outputs. Justice Rhoda Rutto led with 643, followed by Justice Francis Gikonyo with 632, Justice John Robert Wananda with 605, Justice Freda Githiru with 516, Justice Moses Ado with 535, Justice Peter Mulwa with 477 and Justice Benjamin Njoroge with 449.

Other judicial officers included Justice Benard Wafula Murunga, who recorded 76, Justice Letizia Muthoni Wachira with 29 and Justice Winnie Narasha Molonko with two.

The report also provides a glimpse into the work of the Milimani High Court’s Constitution and Human Rights Division, one of the Judiciary’s most consequential divisions because of its mandate to interpret the Constitution and determine disputes involving fundamental rights and freedoms.

In that division, the listed judicial officers included Justice Patricia Nyaundi, who recorded 601 outputs, Justice Gregory Mutai with 516 and Presiding Judge Roselyne Aburili with 450.

Justice Joseph Kipkoech Biomdo recorded 19 outputs at the Milimani Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Division. 

The Criminal Division recorded 905 outputs, with Justice Alexander Muteti leading at 399, followed by Justice Kanyi Kimondo with 209, Justice Margaret Muigai with 193 and Justice Martin Muya with 104.

In the Family Division, Justice Lucy Gitari recorded 745 outputs, Justice Helene Namisi 744, Justice Hilary Chemitei 672, Justice Caroline Kendagor 620, Justice Robinson Ondieki 88 and Justice Roseline Oganyo 61.

The Judicial Review Division recorded 1,383 outputs, with Justice William Musyoka leading at 732, followed by Justice Tabitha Wanyama with 623 and newly appointed Justice Nabil Orina with 26.

Court of Appeal and Supreme Court

The Court of Appeal report also provides a breakdown of decisions made by constituted benches, allowing readers to examine the output of different combinations of judges.

The highest recorded bench output was 172 determinations by a Kisumu bench comprising Justices Hellen Omondi, Luka Kimaru and Milton Makhandia. The bench delivered 115 judgments, four final rulings, 11 interlocutory rulings and 42 other resolutions.

It was followed by a bench comprising Justices Grace Ngenye, Kibaya Laibuta and Kalekye Murgor, based at the Mombasa Court of Appeal, with 100 determinations.

A third bench, comprising Justices Abida Ali-Aroni, Jessie Lesiit and Ole Kantai, based at the Nyeri Court of Appeal, recorded 72. A bench comprising Justices John Mativo, Mohamed Warsame and Paul Mwaniki Gachoka, based at the Nakuru Court of Appeal, recorded 60.

Another bench, comprising Justices Grace Mumbi Ngugi, George Odunga and Daniel Musinga, based at the Nairobi Court of Appeal, recorded 49.

At the bottom end, several constituted benches recorded only one determination each during the reporting period. These included benches comprising Justices Luka Kimaru, Milton Makhandia and Francis Tuiyott, and Justices Weldon Kipyegon, Patrick Kiage and Kathurima M’Inoti.

Unlike the Court of Appeal, the Supreme Court report does not rank individual benches. It presents the court as one collegial bench, with all seven justices listed collectively for the reporting period.

The report shows that the Supreme Court, led by Koome, with Deputy Chief Justice Philomena Mwilu and Justices Mohamed Ibrahim, Smokin Wanjala, Njoki Ndung’u, Isaac Lenaola and William Ouko, recorded 92 collective bench determinations. They comprised 24 judgments, 35 final rulings, 22 interlocutory rulings and 11 other resolutions.

Magistrates and overall output

The magistrates’ schedules reveal another striking disparity. Milimani-based Magistrate Rose Mugeni Ndombi recorded the highest individual output, with 3,929 determinations, followed by Magistrate Paul Mutai with 3,563. Gilbert Omuyaku Shikwe recorded 2,723, Eric Otieno Wambo 2,697 and Charles Ariba Kutwa 2,575.

At the lower end, the report records two determinations for Magistrate Elisha Komora Dullu, 11 for Faith Kawira Muguongo and 12 for Caroline Kainyu Kimathi.

Across the six court categories, the Judiciary recorded 672,794 individual judicial outputs. The Magistrates’ Courts accounted for 473,287, followed by the Small Claims Court with 81,178, the High Court with 50,839, the Kadhis’ Courts with 48,493, the Environment and Land Court with 12,655 and the Employment and Labour Relations Court with 6,342.

The Judiciary insists the figures should not be mistaken for a ranking.

“Judicial performance has many dimensions, and numerical output alone cannot measure it,” the report states.

It cautions that cases differ in complexity, with some involving extensive records, multiple parties, lengthy hearings and substantial legal research.

The disclosure therefore raises a wider accountability question: should the Judiciary move beyond publishing raw numbers and introduce a comprehensive scoring system that considers the quality of judgments, the complexity of disputes, the time taken to determine cases and the age of pending matters?

For thousands of Kenyans who have waited years for justice, the figures offer a new window into the institution that determines their legal fate.

Share this story
.
RECOMMENDED NEWS