Relief for Malava MP as court dismisses petition
Western
By
Mary Imenza and Benard Lusigi
| May 16, 2026
Malava MP David Ndakwa has secured a major legal victory after the Kakamega High Court dismissed a petition challenging his election in the recent by-election.
Justice Stephen Mbugi ruled that the petition filed by Ndakwa’s rival, Seth Panyako, lacked merit, effectively affirming Ndakwa as the duly elected Member of Parliament for Malava Constituency.
The judge held that the petitioner had failed to provide sufficient evidence to warrant nullification of the election results declared by the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC).
Justice Mbugi also dismissed claims that Ndakwa unlawfully contested the parliamentary seat while serving as a Member of County Assembly (MCA).
In his judgment, the judge observed that Section 43(6) of the Elections Act does not expressly require an MCA to resign before vying for another elective seat in a by-election, unlike provisions applicable during a general election.
READ MORE
Push for cryptocurrency regulation gathers pace
How high-stakes home ownership dreams are shattered by city cartels
South Sudan justifies Crawford Capital Port collection role
Farmers risk losing half their harvest, agency warns
Afreximbank bets on $10bn crisis fund, gold bank to bolster African sovereignty
Africa-France summit ends with push to overhaul key trade rules
Ecobank, AGRA partner to boost agricultural financing
Kenya's infrastructure push drives demand for heavy machinery
Kenya targets North African startups in regional innovation push
French firms target Kenya housing sector after Africa summit
“The law does not provide for automatic vacation of office. In my opinion, if Parliament intended that an MCA seeking election as MP should first resign, it would have stated so expressly,” ruled Justice Mbugi.
The court consequently dismissed the petition and upheld Ndakwa’s victory.
The petition had revisited claims of voter bribery, violence, intimidation and alleged involvement of public officials in the highly contested by-election.
During submissions, counsel for the petitioner Nelson Havi argued that the integrity of the election had been compromised beyond repair.
He referred to video footage allegedly showing Higher Education Principal Secretary Beatrice Inyangala distributing relief food while invoking Ndakwa’s candidacy, arguing that the conduct amounted to unlawful participation of state officers in politics.
The petitioner also alleged widespread violence during the election period.
However, the defence team led by lawyer Hezron Abok dismissed the petition as defective and unsupported by credible evidence.
Abok argued that parts of the petition relied on repealed laws and questioned the validity of some affidavits presented before the court.
He maintained that no direct link had been established between Ndakwa and the alleged acts of violence.